Saturday, May 31, 2014

Never Left the Basics

Firefighter Training: Never Left The Basics
Article • January 30th, 2013

How often do you hear the term “back to the basics” thrown around in the fire service world? It is a term that reminds us to go back to the beginning and revisit some of the first skill sets you learned as a firefighter recruit. One question that keeps popping up in my head is why did we leave the basics to begin with?

As I approach my 20th year in the fire service, having served with a number of different sized fire departments, I believe it is a direct result of many factors including distracted leaders, training plans that get too complicated, complacency and overconfident firefighters losing interest in what we “already know.” Let us look at why the back to the basics term simply needs to be eliminated from our vocabularies. We should change it to “never left the basics.”

Distracted Leaders
The managers of today’s fire service are dealing with more and more issues. From increased call volumes to an all-hazards response plans, many leaders can lose focus on some of the most important functions: fireground work. All the planning, preparation and funding don’t really matter when it’s game time if their front line firefighters can’t pull a hoseline and make a push. Understanding that basic skills should be practiced constantly by all firefighters will reduce the risk of injury or death of their crew members.    

Training officers, fireground commanders and chief officers should keep this function in mind when planning their training calendar. Reviewing basic skills should play a part of all training evolutions. If a firefighter is found to be lacking a needed skill, the officer should set aside time for one-on-one interaction. Discovering the need for remediation is best served on the training grounds where no one’s life is at risk and time can be spent on fine-tuning the skill set.  It can be a challenge to keep more experienced firefighters interested in a continual stream of “basic” skills, so a wise manager will involve these folks in the teaching, planning and reviewing to use their experience and allow them to take ownership in the program. 

Complex Training Plans
Now, talking to the training officers, it’s time to take a look in the mirror and see if you have lost focus on the main goal. The goal of any training plan should be to prepare firefighters to manage an emergency safely and confidently. This doesn’t always involve boxes filled with wires, floors that drop out or elaborate training props. Those objects are all great tools for teaching firefighters, but have limitations due to cost and preparation. Props like this cost money that is not always available to us due to a number of budget issues. They also consume our time when we have to build them and that is time you could be spending on building the skills necessary to make your firefighters ready.  
This may not be a problem for some departments because they have a training staff that has enough people to accomplish these tasks simultaneously. Many other departments lean on one or two members to run a training division, which can take them away from their main purpose, training firefighters. Throwing ladders, packaging a downed firefighter or pulling a crosslay does not need fancy props, they need aggressive firefighters who are not afraid to get sweaty while being motivated and educated by a training officer that is passionate about preparing them for their next fire. These “basic” skills should never be referred to as “back to anything.” These skills should never have been left!  Practice them until you are proficient in any weather condition.

Complacency
I know this topic gets beat down like a dead horse, but I strongly believe that complacency is a huge hurdle that we all face. “I’ve been to a thousand fires like this and I don’t need to crawl around on the floor training because I have been a firefighter for X number of years.” Really? Just too many variables need to be trained on constantly throughout your entire firefighting career. Some examples of these are air consumption rate, fitness levels and just plain old rust! Yes, I said rust, like the kind the kind that accumulates on a piece of metal that has been sitting out for an extended period. Rust can gather on us all, even if we only stop training for a short amount of time.

How many times have you ran a fire where the first hoseline stretched ends up looking like a unsprung coil of wire instead of a nicely laid out hoseline? If you don’t take the time to keep these skills fresh by practicing them, the rust will gather and your performance will suffer. Many firefighters who don’t receive training can go a year or more without pulling a hoseline off the engine. How can we expect them to operate efficiently at a fire scene if they have not pulled hose in over a year? You can’t, that’s the main focus of this article.

However, complacency steps in on a company level. I often hear statements like, “How many ways are there to pull a crosslay anyway?” or “I'm not a rookie why do I need to practice that?” Being respectful of the firefighters with years of experience, when was the last time you did it 100 percent correctly and efficiently? I have been pulling hose for a number of years too and the last time that I did it was not perfect, so I could use some more practice. Is perfection attainable or realistic? Probably not, but we should all chose to chase it when we are practicing. Realizing that you have become complacent is the first step toward fixing this problem.

Overconfident Firefighters
Doing our job requires us to have confidence in crew members and ourselves. From time to time I see this concept taken to the extreme. To the point where the cockiness blinds them from realizing that they still need to review the most basic functions. We all want to think that we can do our jobs proficiently and most can, but sometimes that confidence can get you in trouble. Just because you can vent a roof in a minute tonight does not mean that you could do it a year later if you have not practiced it. Most skills that we use are perishable. Meaning if you don’t use them you will lose them.
This is where the “back to the basics” concept really confuses me. If our skills are perishable, outside conditions can affect us and our fitness levels go up and down, why do we ever leave the basics? Overconfidence plays a huge roll in this. I am not trying to bash anyone. Fact of the matter is many things have influence on your performance and overconfidence should not be one of them. Should we be aware of gaps in our skill set, understand our fitness level and train in any type of weather? Yes! The only way that you will find a deficiency is by doing the skill; wouldn’t you rather find this out in training? Determining that you forgot how to manage an SCBA emergency as it is happening is not optimal. We need to make this discovery in a controlled environment like training. 

Just like training, deficiencies in our fitness levels go up and down. Family, other jobs, and life’s distractions can lead to big gaps in working out. Before you know it, you have gone from completing your first half marathon to back out of shape. Fitness needs to be part of our lives every day. For the weather aspect, there is no excuse for not being acclimated to every season. Start slow and get prepared for the hot or cold. The main point that I want to hit home is that you do not want to let your overconfidence talk you out of doing it. “I don’t need to wear my gear at a brush fire in the heat, I've been fighting fires in it for X number of years.”

Conclusion
So, are you ready to forget the “back to the basics” slogan?
The point of this article is to help you realize that we should never have to go back to something that we never leave. Grab some firefighters, set a few goals and get to work. Don’t get lost in setting up elaborate drills, props or plans, just get out and build firefighters who can function in any condition. Voltair once said “Perfection is the enemy of good enough.”

Do not strive to make training a perfect scenario; make it good enough so your firefighters get the basics skills down to where they perform the same way every day! Build their confidence and always keep their ego’s in check by offering them solutions to their deficiencies without making them feel insecure. We want humble, wise and proficient firefighters riding in our seats. I would feel proud as a chief if I knew that my fire department is as fully ready as possible for the next run because we never left the basics. The only thing we need to get back to is the next basic skills session.
RYAN PENNINGTON

Are you Compliant Complacent?

What is this term "Compliant Complacency" you ask?  Well to be honest we are seeing more of it not only on the training ground but at fires as well. The underlying cause is textbook training.  When we drive training to "the standard" we often produce compliant testing results that may not be best suited for real world situations.
 
When we teach classes like our Critical Decision Making Under Fire or Thermal Insult Recognition, we focus heavily on having a better understanding of the limitations of our PPE. Unfortunately though (in my opinion) some firefighters have been mislead along the way. Before we get all hysterical saying NOT TRUE, hear me out.  We all can agree that our (PPE) our Personal Protective Ensemble is absolutely critical to going home at the end of an incident... But most firefighters have no idea how their PPE was designed, tested and how it really protects us. And we didn't even mention to what degree will that PPE provide protection!  Case in point in the photo below: Why would a firefighter wear his or her protective hood this way?  
Now some instructors will take exception to the answer. But here it is... Because somebody allowed it to happen. Good instructors know that muscle memory is established through repetition of a skill set. Now take that repetition and focus on quality assurance that "No bare skin is showing" during donning drills; GOOD. Then benchmark these drills with quantitative testing for time. (tick-tock, tick-tock)  Focusing on these two points for compliance can simply create bad habits. Habits that instructors or testers may have instilled in that firefighter. A hood donned like the one shown above offers the firefighter less than 25% visibility and absolutely no peripheral vision. We are already handcuffed with today's hostile fire environment, why would you want to go into battle with just 25% visibility?  (SA) Situational Awareness - Training for the environment you are expected to work in!  Firefighters that are exposed to regular training the use backwards hoods for SCBA confidence; often see no problem with just 25% visibility. Why? because most of the time they were exposed to 0% visibility from a hood worn in reverse! Isn't that the definition of "Training to Failure". But hey hoods worn like this will provide additional protection to that mask lens and they have no bare skin showing!  Real world tactics require us to make critical decisions under fire which in reality requires the use of ALL of our heightened senses!
 
Properly Donned PPE Hood
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The next issue with complacency is how this helmet is donned in the above photo. The ear flaps on that helmet are tucked up within the ratchet system, thus NOT providing the firefighter with a multi-layered protection factor. Remember your ear flaps are part of the "engineered" ensemble. Lastly, the ratchet itself appears to be adjusted way too tight. Just look how high the helmet is worn on the firefighter's head. This decreases personal protection THREE ways: 1. increased exposure of the forehead and above the ears which has no impact protection,  2. the impact liner (break-away feature) is not secured enough to work as designed when the helmet is struck with rotational force, and 3. riding this high adds to the amount of the surface area which is only protected by the protective hood itself from heat.

FETC NUGGET: Helmets worn this tight will increase your chances of getting BURNED another way too. Not seen or found in any textbook! You see energy from thermal insult can transfer directly to your head when worn too tight.
 
An exposed ratchet is NOT how the manufacture intended the helmet to be worn during a fire. The ear flaps not only protect your ears but it protects the ratchet and the impact liner as well! Transferred heat energy CAN cause a burn through conduction. A ratchet can only absorb so much energy before it heat syncs that energy to nearby objects. A hood was worn properly and was in place during the above injury. The energy caused a burn where the ratchet met the back of the user's head.  Engineered air spaces and designed coverage is a VERY critical component of your PPE and the available protection factors.

When we teach Critical Decision Making Under Fire and our Thermal Insult Recognition programs, firefighters will often say they learned things today that should be in firefighter 1 curriculums worldwide. 
Staying ahead of the curve with street smart credibility...

Hump Day SOS - College Is Not Knowledge


This week is another retro-SOS from my original first few months. These were pictures only so now that we are broadcasting out to the FE community and in full blog mode I will add some commentary. Again, if you already saw this one I hope you get another laugh or affirmation that you are not alone in your thinking.

Is your promotional system producing the results that make a positive difference in your department? Many departments have abandoned the notion that experience makes for better decision making and base promotions solely on certification and formal educational achievements. Where is the balance? There are some departments however that have realized that qualified and certified are two real different achievements and evaluate candidates accordingly. We can’t lose site of the fact that firefighting is a trade skill and a balance of education and experience is necessary in order to progress from apprentice to master. This journey does not occur from spending all your time in the classroom or online. Can a department create a process that evaluates the knowledge, skills and abilities necessary to perform the job of company officer? Is it easier to only require an achievement that assumes qualification? If you are promoting a company officer that is going to have the responsibility of managing personnel on a fire ground you need to have a process for evaluating how they operate. This can be accomplished by using a fire command simulator designed for first due officers. If you are expecting them to handle personnel disputes then see how they actually handle a role player with an issue. No process is a perfect representation of reality but these two techniques give you a much better snap shot than do a simple question and answer panel. Almost anyone can memorize a checklist and hit all the buzz words but not everyone can execute, adapt and perform. Turn what has become an easy and cheap way out upside down. Count the certificates and education to break the tie scores but put your money on the actual performance of the individual.

The most decorated man in Marine Corps history, Chesty Puller, said at his retirement, “….I feel the Marine Corps has become over educated and under experienced…..” These words are haunting as we look at the emphasis on obtaining paper as opposed to being able to perform a skillful hose stretch, maintain accountability of a crew in a smoke filled 5th floor apartment, be able to mix fuel at 100:1 and know which saw it goes in, know the effects of ventilation, fire load and flow paths, know when the nozzle flow is effective or ineffective and why, know how to search from the area of high probability and risk to the lowest, know what a change in interior conditions feels like. Although there is value, none of these are mastered through attending PowerPoint lectures or online discussion groups. Robert Greenleaf who made famous the term “servant leadership” achieved many higher education accomplishments but felt compelled to sum up with his own epitaph which states, “Potentially a good plumber; ruined by a sophisticated education.” The fact is we need tradesmen in order to get the job done. It is the delivery of service that is the reason for our organizational existence. We should not be creating an environment in which the skilled expert craftsman are looked down upon as inferior species because they have not attended the “university”.

College isn’t knowledge and we should encourage and emphasize the importance of learning and mastering the trade skills to new members before they start logging on to the computer and completing assignments in the confines of the bunkroom. They will get much more from their education if they have a solid foundation in the TRADE of firefighting and we will all be “safer” for it. Firefighting is a “dirty job” it is not the corporate America that many uniformed wannabe CEO’s are trying to make it. Trying to turn Incident Commanders into financial analysts is like trying to turn Truckies into figure skaters. For everyone’s sake please promote experience and knowledge and not just certificates and college! Our members lives depend on it!!

Controlling the Flow Path and Door Control

Co-written by P.J. Norwood and Sean Gray

By this point we have not found anyone that does not debate the importance door control. Heck, we have been preaching door control during fire prevention talks for many years. We just never tied it into our tactical mind set outside of trying to keep fire in its compartment. Truck company firefighters have been practicing door control during search and VES for many years!

Understanding and realizing we need to control the door for many is the easy piece that has been missing. The hard part is applying it to the fireground. For some departments door control is not complicated as they have the staffing to position a firefighter at the door. But, there are many fire departments across the nation that do not have the necessary staffing. Some will argue that those departments should not be conducting interior operations. That is another conversation we will not address today.

How do we accomplish door control on the fireground? The easy answer is to have someone close the door behind the advancing company and maintain that position until the water is flowing. Then secure the door open and move to another assigned task.

How do we accomplish this if we do not have a firefighter we can assign to this position? Some have suggested a pro-active rapid intervention team (RIT) can position one of their members here. While we agree this would work we are also tentative. We are advocates of pro-active RIT and feel this is pro-active. However, if there is a smoke condition the door control firefighter needs to be on air. We do not want a RIT member using air during proactive assignments. Some have suggested just close the door and not station a firefighter at the door. This suggestion, we are troubled with. If interior companies need to rapidly withdraw we predict some trouble when they reach the door. If we are talking residential fires the entry door will be inward swinging. Therefore the companies who are rapidly exiting can end up piled up behind the door. The exact reason why commercial doors are outward swinging with panic bars. The other piece is the door will not be controlled. It will simply be closed onto the advancing hose line. This can interfere with the stretch therefore defeating the goal to get water on the fire.

The fire service manufacturers have looked to help us with this dilemma. Their answer adopted from the European fire service are door curtains or block aids as they are referred to in Germany. Door curtains may not be the answer either. However, they are definitely something that we should be considering!

Recently the authors had the ability to teach a flow path management class and we incorporated the Tempest door curtains. In groups of two the instructors took students into the burn building. Upon entry the door was opened and the flow path was immediately visible. The students crawled down the hallway to the door of the burn room. Here we discussed the neutral plane and bi-directional flow. At this point a second crew placed a curtain at the entry door. The students were able to see a decrease in the flow path and after a brief period we witnessed a slight decrease in temperatures. The temperatures were not monitored with any remote equipment. The instructors utilized Thermal Imager Camera’s to monitor the temperatures. The students quickly visualized a decrease in the velocity and movement of the smoke and products of combustion.

Students were then brought into a room off the hallway and searching in the flow path was discussed. We focused on door control during search, walking the walls and numbering the walls to incorporate a search plan. When the search was completed firefighters moved back to the hallway where they immediately noticed a change in conditions. We saw decreased visibility from the blocking of smoke. The smoke did not have an outlet therefore there was no flow path. The crew then crawled down the hallway exiting through the curtain.

What did the students learn and what messages were reinforced? The students all had the opportunity to see observe how a flow path can be effected by door control. We also discussed some fire behavior observations such as neutral plane and bi-directional flow uni-directional flow path. This highlighted the necessity to close doors when searching ahead or above of a hose line until water is flowing.
The students and instructors were also able to see what happens to the interior environment when a curtain is put in place to control the flow path. These were both valuable lessons as we all look forward to adapting our ever changing firegrounds.

What is the future for door curtains? There is a positive future in the American Fire Service for a door curtain! Consider interior doors in the attack stairwell of a high rise fire. Consider smoke control in nursing homes, hospitals, and multifamily dwellings. Each can be a place to utilize a door curtain to stop smoke spread into remote areas.

Curtains also have a place on the fireground for minimal staffed departments who may not have the appropriate staffing to position a firefighter at the door. However, a door curtain should not be used in the place of a door control firefighter! Door control is more than just closing off the inlet. It is one of the most important jobs on the fireground and we need to be sure that our most experienced firefighters are controlling the flow path whether it’s with a door or a curtain.

This is an extremely exciting time in the fire service. Today we are being educated at an alarming rate. It is our job to learn from the scientific research. Then bring the science to the streets, adapt our tactics if and when necessary and share our experiences with each other so we can all learn from experiences both yours and ours.

Every tactic is not for every fire or every fire department. Every fire and fire department are different. You need to adapt when appropriate, evaluate the situation, resources, staffing, building etc. and take all of it into consideration. Then choose a plan that incorporates the science, your training and experiences into a tactical model that is the best for the citizens and the members of your department.

Sunday, May 18, 2014

State: West Firefighters Not Prepared for Fertilizer Plant Fire

"The strategy and tactics utilized by the West Volunteer Fire Department were not appropriate for the rapidly developing and extremely volatile situation," the state fire marshal wrote.  Follow the link below to then entire report form the Texas State Fire Marshal's Office.


Fire Response w/ Limited Staffing

The Firefighters Support Foundation's (FSF) newest training program is now available. Where's the Cavalry? Initial Management of a Structure Fire with Limited Manpower address the problems of volunteer and combination departments that, of necessity, often have skeleton crews initially responding to fires. Whether these initial responders arrive with apparatus or not, there are useful tasks that they can perform until additional apparatus and personnel arrive.


The program consists of a 30-minute video presentation and an accompanying 31-slide PowerPoint. The program is presented by combination department Chief Scott Alderman, a past president of the North Carolina State Firemen's Association.


http://www.fireengineering.com/articles/2014/05/where-s-the-cavalry-training-on-fire-response-with-limited-staffing.html


Thursday, May 8, 2014

SC Firefighters - Helpful Documents

 
Follow the link above where you will find helpful information about guidelines and procedures posted on the SC Firefighters website.  Information that can be found includes the Fire Chief Handbook, Junior Firefighter/Explorer Guidelines and information about how to handle a LODD in your department.

2.5 Hose Drills

Here is a great video posted by way of Fire Service Warrior about controlling and operating the 2.5" hose line.

Nozzle Forward - Aaron Fields

 
 

Tuesday, May 6, 2014

AAS Fire Science - Greenville Tech


Here is an overview of the Associate Degree program in Firefighting Technology at Greenville Technical College.

Sunday, May 4, 2014

Anderson County Training Day

The Anderson County Fire Department will once again be hosting their annual Training Day.  This year two well-known speakers have been invited to share their stories.  Chief Scott Burnette (Asheville Fire Department) and Dr. David Griffin (Charleston Fire Department) will speak on some of the toughest topics firefighters face:  Line of Duty Deaths.  Mark your calendar for June 28th from 8am-5pm and make plans to attend this very informative seminar.

Chief Scott Burnette - Asheville FD




Dr. David Griffin - Charleston  FD

Saturday, May 3, 2014

WELCOME!

Welcome to the new Municipal Officer's Association blog page.  Our plan is to use this resource as a valuable tool to exchange information, post upcoming events, and share thoughts on training and ways to improve our respective departments.  This association began when three municipal departments (Honea Path, Williamston, Belton) saw a need to provide rapid intervention assistance on all structure fires within our districts.  I am proud to say those initial meetings have now grown into the chartering of this association which includes several other departments.  Not only have we continued to meet the rapid intervention challenge, but this organization has addressed many other areas of needed attention.  There is strength in numbers and as the association continues to grow so will our capabilities.