Sunday, September 21, 2014

The Game Has Changed



By Mark vonAppen

The other night I was reminded that we are not always in charge of the way that things turn out.  I saw what it looks like when statistics take precedence of human lives. The other night I was reminded that the game has changed.  There are very specific parameters under which the game is played, and over the past year the rules have been irrevocably altered.  We are not as capable as we once were, and the house called our bluff.  We say it a lot, that someone will pay when the budget forces us to press our luck by making us play short handed, but rarely can we reach out and touch the consequences.  The other night we could touch them and they made us all feel cold and helpless.  

With the change in house rules there are real consequences for not playing along.  I saw it play out in blood, sweat, broken bones, and lives lost. In a nutshell, too many patients, too much twisted metal, and not enough tools to go around.

My mind swirled, "He's really, really bad, and she's really bad too.  You have to pick one because you don't have enough tools to go around.  Take your pick. Heads you lose, tails you lose."
We have to remember that success in our craft doesn't come from holding a good hand, you are judged on what you do when you're dealt a bad hand. 

I was dealt a bad hand and I had to make the better of two no-win decisions.  When the house makes the rules, it wins eventually and I was reminded of just how difficult it is to play against a stacked deck.  I realized again that no matter how good I think I am, I'm not that good.  I watched helplessly as good people tried valiantly to take apart a car with their bare hands as two lives slipped slowly further and further away.

I watched it happen and it was awful.

As the guy who writes and tries to buoy others, I reached out to my network of friends and shared my frustration.  Here is what came back:

You can only do what you can do. We are not superheroes; we are people, just people with a trade to help people. It's not always going to be "ok". Everyone isn't always going to go home. This is a war that will never end for our profession. We do the best we can with what we've got. People get dealt a bad hand and we are there to help, just help. Sometimes we save the day, sometimes we do not. It's how you now handle yourself after defeat that will continue to define you as a firefighter and a human being. Try not to get caught up too much in the what if game. Some of that is always ok as you can learn from shortfalls and better yourself.

Remember, this is a contact sport. You didn't fail with your leadership. Getting back on that rig will help prove that to yourself.


I wasn't alone at this event.  A lot of brothers were there who are hurting afterwards just like me.  What hurts most is that we all know that we used to be able to do a lot more.  The people who make financial decisions (cuts) that limit our ability to respond to emergencies don't have to deal with the fallout, we do.  We are left with the scars. Because we know the difference, it stings that much more.

Sometimes we all need a lift.  I definitely did and still do.  I needed another wake up call. I needed to be reminded that sometimes we all face no-win situations.  I needed to be reminded that we all face the same problems from coast to coast, even around the world, and we are all there for each other.

We have to remember that success in our craft doesn't come from holding a good hand, you are judged on what you do when you're dealt a bad hand.

More on the Mission Statement or Mis-Statement



More on the Mission Statement or Mis-Statement


Earlier on the Hump Day SOS we looked into the mission mis-statements and how far away we have drifted from our original mission “To Save Lives & Property”.  Many of you responded with your own stories of mission creep, incomprehensible jibber jab of corporate speak. Some of you still resist thinking that the fire service is off track and this new mission statement trend is right in line with what troops need.
I have been a little too serious with the HD SOS lately so let’s have some fun. The staff here at the Hump Day SOS went undercover in 100 American fire departments and took hidden double secret video of staff meetings and combined them here in a video so that you, the ordinary men and women of the fire service, could see what is being talked about inside your headquarters……. Enjoy!


http://www.vevo.com/watch/weird-al-yankovic/Mission-Statement/USRV81400344

Terrorism - Are You Ready?


Posted by Mark Munroe

 ISIS, Hamas, Lone Wolf's, Mexican Drug Lords, Etc all have one thing in common, their dislike of the United States, it's government but more importantly, you and your families. A few years ago, while watching my son play with other kids on the playground, I struck up a conversation with an older gentleman watching his grandson interact with mine. We discussed how cute the kids were and how well they got along. Within a few moments, his facial expression changed and I could see he was disturbed about something. I asked him what was wrong and he told me he was from Israel and said to me "Isn't it amazing that some people in this world would stop at nothing to kill those two children playing together, just so they would not grow up to be good and patriotic American's. This my friends is what you, myself, our families and our communities face today, right now.


 We know full well, from our experiences of 9/11/01, Oklahoma City, the Fort Hood shootings, the Newtown shootings, the cinema shootings in Colorado and many, many more, that the United States is no longer immune to terrorism. No longer can we sit back and watch events unfold in other countries and shake our heads in shock and horror. It is now at our front door step. ISIS, as of this writing, is making one to three million dollars a day, selling oil on the black market, imagine that, one to three million dollars a day! It took Osama Bin Laden, millions of his own money and years of preparation for 9/11 and he brought down the two biggest buildings in New York City and with them, thousands of people and first responders, who to this day, are still dying of 9/11 related cancers, 343 and counting. Our boarders are not secure, allowing for an untold amount of people to cross into the country unchecked and undocumented. Who is coming across? What kind of threat do they pose? Has your department or personnel been advised of any possible threats? What to look for? How to react? And more importantly, how to protect yourself from these threats? Is your department ready? Are you?


Recently, I had a situation I was involved with here in New Hampshire with a potential Active Shooter incident in the town I serve as Assistant Chief. South Hampton is only a few miles from Brentwood, NH, the town where police officer Steven Arkell was gunned down in cold blood while answering a domestic dispute call. The house was set on fire by the suspect and we all watched on t.v. as the house exploded. South Hampton, only two weeks later, experienced an incident where a well known subject (well known to the local PD) after being questioned at his home, stole a police cruiser and tried running down two police officers, then ran into the woods. For the first hour, no one from my department was even aware of the situation. It was only when the deputy chief of the town next to us was contacted by their PD of the situation that we were informed. The scene become very confusing, many PD's self deployed, no one could tell myself or the other Assistant Chief who was in charge. Some FD's started self deploying even though they were not called. Command Posts started showing up, personnel from everywhere were walking right into the area. The other chief and myself later found out that our command post was within sight of where PD believed the shooter to be.
 As the department training officer, I started looking around, scouring the country asking questions about Terrorism and Active Shooter training, the basic equipment a fire department might need in these kinds of situations. No one could answer the most simple question, where do I find the needed training. I was continuously told to check with FEMA, which I did. FEMA had some basic courses on terrorism. I checked with other agencies on Active Shooter, I was told there were classes for PD but nothing for Fire/EMS. I continued to ask around the country, who is preparing first responders for the eventual terrorist attack or the active shooter situation? Are our first responders in the smaller communities ready for such events and if not, what is the outcome for these communities and its citizens? After checking around the New England area, the answer I continuously received was "no we are not ready at all" Thirteen years after 9/11 and our firefighters and EMS are still not ready for  a terrorist attack. We certainly see drills once in a while in the larger cities but what about the smaller communities who are going to possibly face the same situation or end up responding mutual aid to the larger cities when all goes to hell? Are your people ready for the next attack that  we have been told over and over again is coming? And if not, where are you and your department going to get this needed training?


 It boggles the mind, with everything that is going on in this world today, the training needed to prepare first responders to face a some kind of terrorist attack is still not available on a large scale. I call on Washington, state authorities and local communities to take action, a strong lead and a sound voice on preparing our first responders for what will eventually come. Fire & EMS Instructors & Training Officers around the country should be demanding this kind of training to prepare their people, their departments and their communities for what could and will turn out to be disastrous turn of events. Does your department, as it stands now, have the training or the trained personnel it needs for not only a terrorist attack but an Active Shooter situation say involving your high school? Are your people prepared for what they will face when they arrive on scene? Are they ready for after the incident, when they go home and face their families and loved ones? Does your community have the resources its going to need for this type of situation and I am not talking about the four wheel Gators you got from a grant. Do you have enough body bags, medical equipment, and the personnel you can count on and know are going to show up? Are your people ready and trained for a car bombing, Anthrax incident, an MCI shooting or a CBRNE attack? If not, where and how are you going to get them trained? Great question!


Please let me know your thoughts, do you agree or disagree, I would be very interested in hearing from you all who have an opinion one way or another. Remember, there is no wrong answers, just a lack of knowledge the we all must overcome and soon.

Rescue: Remove the Victim or Remove the Fire?

Posted by Chris Langlois


            It’s an age old question that is still debated by firefighters to this day, and often quite vigorously. When responding to an occupied residential structure fire, do you immediately go for the rescue to remove the victims or do you attack the fire? Many firefighters would say that you should do both at the same time, and if you have the available resources showing up quick enough to do so, that is probably the most correct answer. However, many times our reality is that we are showing up with a single engine company that must operate for several minutes alone. In those cases, the question of rescue vs. fire attack ceases to be a vigorous firehouse debate and becomes a life or death decision that must be made in seconds by a first arriving company officer.


            Rescue is always our number one priority. It always has been and it always will be, it’s really why we do what we do. However, there are two very appropriate ways of addressing rescue: remove the victim from the fire or remove the fire from the victim. Which of those is correct, as with almost every other decision we make on the fireground, is dependent upon the situation, our available resources and the information we have at the time.


           Often at single family dwelling fires, where there usually (not always but quite often) is one or two victims that require rescue, it may very well be most appropriate for the first arriving personnel who discover a victim while advancing a line to the interior to stop and quickly remove the victim from the hazardous interior of the house. These victims can often be removed quickly, over a short distance through windows or doors that are close by.  If a first arriving crew is able to successfully rescue a victim at a house fire and the structure burns to the ground because fire attack was halted or delayed, we would absolutely consider that a win, as we should. But, what about situations where there may be multiple victims in immediate danger as well as others, perhaps dozens, that will be in immediate danger soon? What about fires in duplexes, fourplexes, hotels, motels, apartment buildings, college dorms, boarding houses, townhomes, assisted living facilities, etc. Are you going immediately into evacuation/search/rescue mode or are you devoting your initial resource(s) to getting water on the fire as quickly and decisively as possible? Bring that question up at the firehouse kitchen table next time and see where it goes!


           To get a better understanding of our own situation, let’s step back and take a look at what others do in similar situations. Showing up with very limited initial staffing at a fast moving fire with many victims in immediate danger pretty much defines what aircraft rescue firefighting (ARFF) personnel are trained to deal with. When ARFF firefighters arrive with six to eight personnel at the crash scene of a 737 aircraft with 132 souls on board and heavy fire showing, they don’t stretch 1-3/4” handlines to the interior and begin to drag individual victims out of the fuselage of the plane. The best chance they have of saving the most lives is to show up and immediately hit the fire with everything they have as quickly as possible, creating rescue corridors to allow ambulatory victims, with the assistance of the flight crew to get themselves out, while buying valuable time for, and removing the immediate hazard from, those unable to rescue themselves. Putting the fire out, or at least drastically reducing the amount of fire, as quickly as possible makes everything better for everyone all the way around.


          Sitting in a non-stressful environment, reading this article, it may seem like a simple common sense decision to “just go put the fire out”, but it must be a decision you think about before the incident happens and that you are prepared to make. It is a difficult decision that you are going to have to make at 2:00am, when you are advancing a line down a long hot hallway towards a fast moving fire in an apartment and you begin to encounter victims down in your path. Do you stop and begin to drag bodies out or do you step over them and continue to move the line down the hallway to get water on the fire? It’s an emotional decision that you will have to make, quickly in an extremely stressful situation. It’s a decision you have to discuss with your crew before it happens, so they are prepared when you make it.


          Take a look at how our brothers and sisters in law enforcement have changed their tactics when faced with that same decision while responding to active shooter incidents. Since the 1999 active shooter incident at Columbine High School, law enforcement has been rethinking their approach to responding to these incidents. Instead of arriving, barricading the area, evacuating people from inside and treating it as a hostage incident, officers are now being trained to enter and engage the shooter as quickly as possible. In doing so, they will undoubtedly encounter injured and dying victims. At that point, every officer will have to make a conscious decision to either stop, provide aid and attempt to remove each victim encountered, or to move past them to find and engage the continuing threat. In a recent report titled “The Police Response to Active Shooter Incidents” the Police Executive Research Forum states that, “Active shooter polices are built around the reality that even a one-minute delay in responding may result in multiple additional fatalities. Officers should focus on stopping the shooter as their priority, rather than assisting victims whom they may encounter as they search for the shooter. The priorities are: (1) stop the shooter; (2) assist the wounded; and (3) evacuate people from the scene” (Police Executive Research Forum, 2014). It’s a tough decision, but law enforcement knows that their best chance at saving the most lives involves finding and eliminating the growing threat as quickly as possible. The longer they wait the more time allowed for the shooter to continue to target more victims including officers attempting to aid injured civilians. Even with a limited number of initial arriving officers, engaging and neutralizing the threat as quickly as possible makes everything better for everyone. It stops the forward progress of the shooter, protects other threatened civilians from further harm, reduces the continued risk to responding officers and allows help to reach victims already injured.


          Even in single family house fires, the best way for the first arriving engine company to protect victims may be to quickly advance a line to confine and extinguish the fire in order to protect the survivable spaces within the house where victims may still be alive.


          Apartment building fires that start on an exterior balcony due to discarded smoking materials is not an uncommon occurrence. Firefighters are often greeted with a fast moving fire extending up the exterior of the building and impinging upon the soffits, threatening to enter or already in the attic. These fires are often called in by a passersby because occupants of the building are unaware of the presence of the external fire. In some cases the building’s fire detection and alarm system has not activated. Often the first inclination of firefighters is to enter and begin evacuation and search operations for occupants, while advancing a line to the interior apartment in an attempt to confront the fire extending up the outside of the building. In these cases, the seat of the fire is on the outside of the building. As with an ARFF response, the best way to protect the most lives may be to hit the extending exterior fire fast and hard utilizing the first arriving engine company’s deck gun or a 2 ½” line deployed to the exterior of the building if apparatus cannot readily access the area of the external fire. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZTFCeW3wf0
Interior lines can then be advanced to the interior to assess for extension of fire inside the building, especially in the attic. If the alarm system has not activated, firefighters can initiate it utilizing a manual pull station, allowing occupants to begin evacuating. Quickly hitting and overwhelming the fire also applies to those house fires that start on the back deck from a grill or other exterior ignition source and is extending up the outside of the rear of the house when the fire department arrives. Some would say that this initial exterior tactic is a defensive operation and we should not be defensive if there are occupants in the building. We need to re-examine our definition of offensive and defensive strategy, defining them not based on the location of your attack (exterior/interior) but rather on your strategy. Aggressively attacking the seat of the fire from any location in order to knock down the main body, buys you time and enables you to protect occupants and to quickly follow up the exterior attack with a more effective and safer interior attack. That’s about as offensively aggressive as you can get.


When considering fire attack to help achieve rescue, the following two points are also important:
  • Getting water on the fire quickly to support rescue means that you also must be flowing enough gallons per minute to make a difference. Advancing a 1 ¾” to confront a 2 ½” fire because it’s quicker defeats the purpose if you are not able to put the fire out. Speed comes from skill, and skill comes from training and repetition. Be as good with the big line as you are with the 1 ¾”.
  • “Softening the target” supports rescue. The recent UL/NIST studies have shown that when done properly, getting water on the fire quickly, even from the exterior, improves conditions throughout the structure and makes the interior more survivable for victims as well as supporting a more effective interior attack following the external application of water.
         It is very difficult to write down in an SOP/Policy/Guideline, every decision firefighters and officers should make in any given situation, and there are few things for which we can definitely say ALWAYS do this or NEVER do that. Decisions have to be made by trained and experienced individuals who are on scene, based on the situation they find, the resources they have and the information they have available to them at the time the decision is made. We must arm our personnel with the knowledge of not only what to do and how to do it, but also a good understanding of where, when and more importantly why, so that they can make difficult fireground decisions better.


        I’m not saying that we should abandon rescue or that civilian life safety should be a lower priority so that we can go in and fight fire. Just the opposite, I’m saying that we should consider the best way to effect rescue and ensure the protection of life, based on the situation. If you arrive initially with enough resources to attack, confine and extinguish the fire while simultaneously searching for and rescuing victims, great. If not, assess the situation, the resources you have, and the information available to you, and be prepared to make the decision to either remove the victims from the fire or remove the fire from the victims.